Shapeways 3D Printspiration

Shapeways is the world’s leading 3D Printing marketplace and community.

Welcome to the Future of Stuff.

Visit us at https://www.shapeways.com/
Recent Tweets @
This is Awesome
Posts tagged "patent"

Shapeways Talks 3D Printing at the US Patent Office in Washington DC

Back in January Shapeways participated in a 3D printing conference at the US Patent and Trademark Office in Washington DC. Alongside representatives from EOS, ExOne, MakerBot, Stratasys and 3D Systems we briefed staff from the USPTO and other interested parties on the history, present and possible futures of 3D printing, and how they might interact with the patent office.

It was a fantastic forward thinking move by the patent office to recognize that this is an area of growth that needs to be nurtured to realize the full potential.  That while still protecting the intellectual property of those engaging in meaningful research, we do not close off the field with broad, over reaching patents that could really hamper the growth.  Along with the representatives of the USPTO and companies involved in 3D printing, there were also interested stakeholders looking at the world of 3D printing and patents from various angles, including those that might try and control 3D printing with a digital rights management system, and others such as the EFF are looking to keep 3D printing as open as possible.

Before you decide which side of the fence you sit on, be sure to read Michael Weinberg’s white paper entitled It Will Be Awesome if They Don’t Screw it Up: 3D Printing, Intellectual Property, and the Fight Over the Next Great Disruptive Technology to see how patents play into the growth of 3D printing technology while his latest paper looks closer at copyright, patent and trademark for people using the 3D printers to make amazing things. like you.

Simultaneous Innovation and 3D Printing: Updated

As the tools of manufacture become available to more people through 3D printing, we are going to see an increasing number of products that are very similar to each other hit the market/internet at exactly the same time. The whole issue of patents, ownership and attribution of ideas is also going to become increasingly complex as simultaneous innovation occurs.

We recently featured The Canon Capholder by Spruce (above right) on the Shapeways blog, citing it as a great example of a simple solution to a common problem for all photographers, be they amateur, professional or accidental. At about the same time as Spruce posting his final design on Shapeways, so to did Kitlaan on Thingiverse (above left) and Mark Stevenson on Kickstarter (bottom) having already raised $14,623 after seeking only $3,900 in backing.  There was a little bit of a flurry on the social networks as to which if any of the designs were a copy of the other and it seems as though all three were developed simultaneously without being aware of each others designs. 

Now photographers have been losing lens caps for 150 years now and it was not until the means of production has been put into the hands of the users that we finally have a simple solution.  Camera manufacturers have know it is an issue but instead of coming up with a simple solution to store the lens cap, they instead sell replacements caps.

Now three people around the globe have solved the problem with one looking to take it to mass production, one selling 3D printed versions via Shapeways and the other releasing the STL and the parametric SCAD file under a creative commons license.  Mark Stevenson (taking it to mass production) has apparently applied for a patent for his design but there are already these two examples, and at least two other variations that make aesthetic and functional variations on the creative commons licensed design.  Even if he has been developing for 9 months and testing for 3 additional months he may have difficulty obtaining or enforcing a patent when all of these variations are already out in the world. Will the Shapeways 3D printed version reduce the potential income of the mass produced item and is it worth perusing considering he has already mitigated the risk thanks to the Kickstarter backers.  Would owners of DIY 3D printers forgo $15 when they can squirt hot plastic into the form of their own lens cap holder which could be customized to double as a bottle opener?

All in all an interesting example of the speed of innovation brought about by 3D printing.  That a user’s needs can be met immediately when the user designs a solution for their exact needs. They do not need to buy a generic lens cap holder but can 3D print exactly what they need in the color of their choice.. Take that Henry Ford.

Do you think the patent will be awarded to Mark Stephenson? Should it be? Is it time to re-think patents? What can we do to allow for simultaneous innovation?

UPDATE: Thanks Paul KIng, it seems Nikon has a 2009 Patent that they have just announced early July 2011 for a slightly more advanced lens strap arrangement…. The design is a lot more complex and it seems the patent may be on the mechanism not the use?  This could make it a little more interesting…